Blog

Propagandists love repeating that Islam isn't compatible with the West. You hear it constantly on podcasts and cable news. It's an incredibly tired talking point.

And from a purely moral standpoint today, they actually aren't totally wrong. Islam firmly prohibits usury, gambling, fornication, various haram foods, and the kind of casual promiscuity that dominates modern media. It also completely rejects the weird corporate structure we have where massive financial institutions are legally treated as actual human beings with rights.

Though honestly, a lot of those exact same behaviors were strictly banned in European countries too not that long ago. We just forget. But the real issue here isn't the moral friction—it's the deliberate historical erasure.

John William Draper pointed this out ages ago. As a chemist and historian, he absolutely hated how European literature systematically hid our scientific obligations to Muslims. Just swept it all under the rug.

Robert Briffault flat out said modern science owes its very existence to Arab culture. The ancient world didn't even have actual science before them. They were entirely pre-scientific.

George Sarton backed this up completely. He noted the entire experimental spirit we rely on today in every lab was basically created by Muslims down to the 12th century.

Will Durant knew they weren't just mindless copiers of old texts. They didn't simply hand over Greek math and medicine—they translated everything and actually improved it significantly.

H.G. Wells called it a massive gift of light and power. We got it directly through the Arabs. Not the Latins.

Even King Charles gave a speech at Oxford back in 1993 admitting all of this. He called out our massive, willful ignorance about the sheer debt our own culture and civilization owes the Islamic world.

Bertrand Russell wasn't shy about it either. He rightly noted that Europe was sunk in complete, muddy barbarism while art, poetry, and science flourished in the East.

Just look at Cordova. Victor Robinson wrote about how Europe literally lay in the mud while Cordova had perfectly paved streets and public lamps. Night and day difference.

Philip K. Hitti said absolutely no one in the Middle Ages contributed more to human progress than the Arabic-speaking peoples. Nobody else even came close.

De Lacy O'Leary made the exact same point about intellectual survival. Arabs kept higher intellectual life breathing while the Christian West was busy fighting off utter barbarism.

Carl Sagan agreed. He explicitly wrote that the scientific tradition was kept alive—and actively advanced—in the Islamic world during the absolute darkest ages of Europe.

It wasn't even a competition. W. Montgomery Watt wrote that when Europeans finally started studying Arab scientific works, they found themselves completely and totally outclassed.

Gustave Le Bon literally said translating those Arab books into Latin was the actual starting point of Europe's entire scientific awakening. The spark.

Adam Smith even weighed in on the economics of it. He pointed out the Caliphs created the necessary social tranquility for sciences to actually cultivate in the first place.

John Davenport argued that every scrap of knowledge of math, astronomy, and philosophy in 10th-century Europe came straight from Arabian schools. No exceptions.

Arthur Glenn Leonard said Europeans owe a massive, unparalleled debt of gratitude to the Islamic world for transmitting antiquity to them. We just choose to ignore it.

Max Meyerhof called Islamic medicine and science the absolute most important scientific endeavor to unfold in the Middle Ages. Period.

Rom Landau talked specifically about math. They didn't just synthesize Greek and Hindu mathematics—they injected a completely new vitality into the entire science.

Sigrid Hunke was extremely clear that they weren't just basic transmitters. They created the entirely new scientific civilization that gave Europe its foundation.

Stanwood Cobb went even further with his assessment. He called Islam the virtual creator of the European Renaissance itself.

Carra de Vaux noted they taught the West the use of ciphers. They basically founded the arithmetic of everyday life that we still use right now.

Tim Wallace-Murphy called this knowledge transfer totally neglected. Marmaduke Pickthall pointed out that European Christians literally had to go to Muslims to get any learning. James Burke said they gave us the very concept of backing theory with hard facts. Thomas Arnold said they laid the groundwork for the whole Enlightenment. And the proof is sitting in Washington D.C. right now. Go to the Library of Congress. Look up at the massive mural on the dome of the main reading room. Edwin Blashfield painted it to show the historical pillars of human progress. The figure chosen to represent Physics? Islam.

25 Quotes from Western philosophers, physicists and scientists about Islam's contribution to the West

• John William Draper (Chemist and Historian): "I have to deplore the systematic manner in which the literature of Europe has contrived to put out of sight our scientific obligations to the Mohammedans. Surely they cannot be much longer hidden."

• Robert Briffault (Historian and Surgeon): "The debt of our science to that of the Arabs does not consist in startling discoveries or revolutionary theories; science owes a great deal more to Arab culture, it owes its existence... The ancient world was, as we saw, pre-scientific."

• George Sarton (Pioneer of the History of Science): "The main, as well as the least obvious, achievement of the Middle Ages was the creation of the experimental spirit and this was primarily due to the Muslims down to the 12th century."

• Will Durant (Philosopher and Historian): "The Arab scholars were transmitting to the West not only the mathematics, chemistry, physics, and medicine of the Greeks, but also their own translations and improvements."

• H.G. Wells (Author and Historian): "Through the Arabs it was and not by the Latin route that the modern world received that gift of light and power."

• King Charles III (Speech at Oxford, 1993): "If there is much misunderstanding in the West about the nature of Islam, there is also much ignorance about the debt our own culture and civilization owe to the Islamic world."

• Bertrand Russell (Philosopher and Mathematician): "The supremacy of the East was not only military. Science, philosophy, poetry, and the arts, all flourished in the Muhammadan world at a time when Europe was sunk in barbarism."

• Victor Robinson (Historian of Medicine): "Europe was darkened at sunset, Cordova shone with public lamps; Europe was dirty, Cordova built a thousand baths... Europe lay in mud, Cordova's streets were paved."  

• Philip K. Hitti (Historian): "No people in the Middle Ages contributed to human progress so much as did the Arabians and the Arabic-speaking peoples."

• De Lacy O'Leary (British Orientalist): "The Arabs kept alive the higher intellectual life and the study of science at a time when the Christian West was fighting desperately with barbarism."

• Carl Sagan (Astronomer and Physicist): "In the dark ages of Europe, the scientific tradition was kept alive, and advanced, in the Islamic world."

• W. Montgomery Watt (Historian): "When the Europeans began to study the scientific and philosophical works of the Arabs, they found themselves completely outclassed."

• Gustave Le Bon (Polymath and Sociologist): "The translation of the books of the Arabs into Latin was the start of the scientific awakening of Europe."

• Adam Smith (Economist and Philosopher): "The empire of the Caliphs seems to have been the first state under which the world enjoyed that degree of tranquillity which the cultivation of the sciences requires."

• John Davenport (British Scholar): "It must be owned that all the knowledge whether of physic, astronomy, philosophy or mathematics, which flourished in Europe from the 10th century, was originally derived from the Arabian schools."

• Arthur Glenn Leonard (Scholar): "If ever any people on earth owe a debt of gratitude to another, the European owes it to the Islamic world, for it was the latter that transmitted to it the civilization of antiquity."

• Max Meyerhof (Medical Historian): "Looking back we may say that Islamic medicine and science reflected the light of the Hellenic sun... it was the most important scientific endeavor to unfold in the Middle Ages."

• Rom Landau (Educator and Author): "In mathematics, the Arab contribution was enormous. They not only synthesized Greek and Hindu mathematics, but they injected a new vitality into the science."

• Sigrid Hunke (German Historian): "The Arabs were not just transmitters. They were the creators of a new scientific civilization... that gave Europe its foundation."

• Stanwood Cobb (Educator): "Islam... was the virtual creator of the Renaissance in Europe."

• Carra de Vaux (French Historian of Science): "Arithmetic and algebra also flourished alongside astronomy... The Arabs taught the use of ciphers, and thus became the founders of the arithmetic of everyday life."

• Tim Wallace-Murphy (Historian and Author): "The massive transfer of knowledge from the Islamic world to the West is one of the most neglected elements of European history."

• Marmaduke Pickthall (Western Scholar): "The greatest universities of the world were at that time in the Muslim Empire... the Christians of Europe, if they wanted to get any learning, had to go to the Muslims to get it."

• James Burke (Science Historian): "The Arabs literally gave us the concepts of science we take for granted today. They introduced the idea of experiment, of backing up theory with hard facts."

• Thomas Arnold (British Orientalist): "Islamic science and its methods of observation and measurement laid the groundwork for everything the European Enlightenment claimed as its own."